[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

RE: [b] -- Skinny



>From: Charles Line
>
>For all the lardasses on the list (such as myself).
>
>I've been on the Atkins diet for just over 2 weeks and have lost over a
>stone!!!

Watch out for those kidney stones though:-

http://www.nytimes.com/2002/09/10/health/nutrition/10BROD.html?8vd

High-Fat Diet: Count Calories and Think Twice
By JANE E. BRODY


The debate over high-fat versus low-fat as a means of weight control flared
up again this summer, leaving many weight-conscious Americans thoroughly
confused and most nutrition experts up in arms.

Though billed as a "diet revolution," the high-protein, high-fat, extremely
low carbohydrate diet championed by Dr. Robert C. Atkins is hardly
revolutionary. It was first promoted in the late 1800's by an English coffin
maker and has reappeared periodically in various incarnations, most
successfully since the early 1970's by Dr. Atkins, who promoted it with a
series of books and a clinic that bear his name.

 
Does it help people lose weight? Of course it does. If you cannot eat bread,
bagels, cake, cookies, ice cream, candy, crackers, muffins, sugary soft
drinks, pasta, rice, most fruits and many vegetables, you will almost
certainly consume fewer calories. Any diet will result in weight loss if it
eliminates calories that previously were overconsumed.

This diet seems easy because it places no limits on the amounts of meats,
fats, eggs, cheese and the like you can eat. These foods digest slowly,
making you feel satisfied longer. Also, a diet without carbohydrates causes
the body to make substances called ketones that may create a mild nausea,
suppressing hunger.

But in a major report last week, the Institute of Medicine of the National
Academies emphasized the importance of balance of nutrients, with
carbohydrates - starches and sugars - making up 45 percent to and 65 percent
of daily calories and fats, 20 percent to 35 percent. The panel of 21
scientists also urged Americans to keep as low as possible their consumption
of saturated fats, the foods Dr. Atkins recommends as his diet's main
components.

Testimonials abound from people who have lost scores of pounds - painlessly,
they say - on the Atkins diet. This is not surprising. After all, how much
of a limited category of foods can you eat before you find yourself eating
less and less? With few carbohydrates, the weight initially comes pouring
off - literally - in body water, the first 5 to 10 pounds of weight loss.

One question I'd like to see answered is how long anyone can stay on such a
scheme and what happens when you start adding back some of the wholesome
foods limited or forbidden on this diet, like sweet corn, grapes,
watermelons, potatoes, carrots, beets or oatmeal.

The Great Unknowns A more important question: For those who stick with the
diet, which allows back very limited amounts of carbohydrate-rich foods,
what happens to their health?

In a study by Dr. Chia-Ying Wang and colleagues at the University of Texas
Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas, reported in August in The American
Journal of Kidney Diseases, just six weeks of a low-carbohydrate,
high-protein diet greatly increased the risk of developing kidney stones.
"This study shows that this is not a healthy way to lose weight," Dr. Wang
said.

What is surprising is that after three decades of simmering and soaring
popularity, the Atkins diet has yet to be tested for long-term safety and
effectiveness.

In an interview, Dr. Atkins said: "A long-term study would cost millions and
millions of dollars. We can afford to do a six-month study." Those shorter
studies, he said, have shown "major improvements in lab tests and
well-being." He said his foundation has contributed to a study under way at
Harvard comparing the short-term effectiveness and health effects of diets
low in carbohydrates versus diets low in fat.

Dr. Abby Block, nutritionist at the foundation, said studies of the Atkins
diet lasting six months to a year and extensive clinical experience, have
shown consistent improvements in blood lipids and glucose levels, suggesting
that the diet can improve health despite its high levels of saturated fats
and cholesterol, long associated with heart disease risks.

Why hasn't the government tested it? One possible reason is that it is
unlikely to be approved by any review committee, given what is known about
the effects of animal fats and cholesterol on the risk of heart disease,
strokes and some cancers, as well as accumulating evidence that diets rich
in fruits and vegetables and moderate in protein and fat can prevent
diseases like high blood pressure, prostate cancer, heart disease and
diabetes.

The Atkins diet is shy on several vital nutrients, including the B vitamins
and vitamins A, C and D, antioxidants that slow the effects of aging, and
calcium. And, a diet rich in animal protein can draw calcium from the bones,
increasing the risk of osteoporosis and hip fractures.

What Are the Facts?


The Atkins diet is attractive to many Americans who have found it hard to
lose weight on a low-fat diet. In recent decades, as Americans have been
admonished to eat less fat, levels of obesity continued to rise, a situation
noted in a recent article in The New York Times Magazine by Gary Taubes, a
science writer, who told me he had lost considerable weight on the Atkins
diet.

But many well-established facts can explain what happened to the American
figure without damning carbohydrates or blaming low-fat diets, per se. 

First, Americans are simply eating more - an average of 400 calories a day
more than they did decades ago. Four hundred calories times 365 days divided
by 3,500 (the amount of calories in a pound of fat) equals 41.7 pounds
gained in a year, all other things being equal.

Of course, the caloric increase did not happen overnight, but the gradual
increase, with little or no increase in caloric output from physical
activity, can easily explain the creeping obesity that is now approaching a
gallop.

Second, portion sizes have ballooned. A double cheeseburger, jumbo fries and
supersize soda may be a single meal at a restaurant, but they contain all
the calories a person should consume in an entire day. In a recent survey by
the American Institute for Cancer Research, two-thirds of diners said they
ate all they were served - at one sitting - most or all of the time.

When nutrition experts began urging Americans to cut back on fats, many
filled in by eating more carbohydrates - a lot more than anyone recommended.
Food producers jumped on the bandwagon to produce low-fat snacks and
desserts, and Americans went hog wild, eating as much of them as they
wanted.

Many fat-free foods have as many calories, or nearly as many, as their
original high-fat versions, since sugars and other carbohydrates replace the
fat and reduce the loss of flavor.

Third, Americans are not eating a low-fat diet. Despite a decline in the
percentage of fats in the American diet, most people still eat the same
amount. As caloric intake rose, the percentage of fat calories dropped but
the total amount did not. Americans are eating more of everything,
especially refined carbohydrates, which are made from white flour and
sugars, doing neither their health nor their waistlines any good.

Too many refined carbohydrates can raise blood levels of heart-damaging
triglycerides and may increase the risk of diabetes as well as obesity.
Neither is it wise to cut out all fats. The body needs fat to aid in the
absorption of essential nutrients, fat enhances flavor and satiety, and some
fats actually promote health.

These ideas are not new. Several years ago, I wrote that healthful dietary
fats found in foods like avocados, nuts and fish belong in the diet, both
for disease prevention and weight control. I quoted Dr. Margo Denke of
Southwestern Medical Center: "The swing back to Atkins is a response to the
fact that a low-fat diet hasn't worked for a lot of people because they
stuff in carbohydrates."

To which Dr. Alice H. Lichtenstein, professor of nutrition at Tufts
University in Boston, added: "Reducing fat alone is no guarantee of weight
loss. You must cut calories or increase physical activity."

Dr. Denke concurred: "No matter what anyone tells you, it's calories that
count. Carefully controlled metabolic studies show that it doesn't matter
where extra calories come from. Eat more calories than you expend and you'll
gain weight."


Join us at Sibos in Geneva, September 30 - October 4 and discover how our Operational Risk Management solution has helped financial organisations worldwide to increase STP, control risk and optimise efficiency. See <http://www.swift.com/> for more details. 

On the Tuesday evening of Sibos join Accurate Software and our industry partners for a VIP drinks reception at 17.30, Attic Bar, Villa Sarasin, right next door to the Palexpo Conference Centre.


Accurate Software Ltd 

The Courtyard, Denmark Street, Wokingham, RG40 2AZ, UK.
Tel: +44 (0)118 977 3889
Fax +44 (0)118 977 1260
Web: http://www.accurate.co.uk

The information in this email is confidential and privileged and is intended only for the use of the individual or entity listed above.  If you are neither the intended individual, or entity listed above, nor the person responsible for the delivery of this email to the intended recipients, you are hereby notified that any unauthorised distribution, copying or use of this email is prohibited.  If you have received this email in error, please notify the Accurate system manager at postmaster@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx or on +44 (0)118 977 3889.  The views expressed in this communication may not necessarily be the views held by the Accurate Group.


 Bemli: weeks or months away from nuclear capability

* Last Subject: RE: [b] -- Skinny --*
* Last Date: Wed, 2 Oct 2002 09:39:50 -0000  --*
* 10:52-12 --*